Summary:
CIPPEC (Centro de Implementación de Políticas Públicas para la Equidad y el Crecimiento ) has been denied access to information concerning the beneficiaries of subsidies and social cash transfer programs in 2006 and 2007. The Supreme Court considered that accessing such data has a clear public interest, since it enables social accountability on how competent public officials allocate these subsidies. The Court noted that a request of this nature does not infringe the right to privacy as it does not seek to gather indiscreet information on the beneficiaries. It noted that ensuring access to this type of information is critical to ensure social accountability of state decisions, and compliance with the principles of rationality, effectiveness and efficiency. By providing access to such information, far from stigmatizing beneficiaries, the Government contributes to ensure equity.
Access to information about beneficiaries to ensure social accountability of state decisions
- Country
- Argentina
- Body
- Argentina - Supreme Court (Corte Suprema de Justicia de la Nación), Supreme Courts
- Case
- Centro de Implementación de Políticas Públicas para la Equidad y el Crecimiento (CIPPEC) vs. Ministerio de Desarrollo Social
- Case number
- 1172/03
- Year of judgement
- 2014
Related Key Issues
Topical issues
This section highlights some issues of current interests: 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and development assistance Environmental sustainability, climate change and the green economy Financial crisis and consolidation/expansion measures Fragile states and post-crisis contexts Informality and transitions to formality New technologies and the gig economy Poverty, inequality and standards of living Domestic workers Workers in…
Governance, accountability and democracy
Despite several countries have been able to extend social protection coverage, the right to social protection remains still unfulfilled for a large part of the population. Several States have not included yet this right into their national legal framework and are not responsible for its realization. Where instead the realization of social protection as a…
Disadvantaged and vulnerable groups
Social protection systems using a rights-based framework should mainstream inclusion in their design, implementation and evaluation to ensure that they are accessible by all those who suffer from structural discrimination (such as women, children, older persons, persons with disabilities, ethnic minorities, indigenous peoples and people living with HIV/AIDS), and do not stigmatize beneficiaries. Due to…
Gender
Social protection systems have the potential to transform social and economic gender dynamics. However, to achieve this end, they must be designed taking into account the different types of risks and vulnerabilities to poverty experienced by men and women; the underlying causes of discrimination against and exclusion of women; and explicitly integrate women’s specific needs…
Financing
Sustainable financing and sound delivery structures are key factors for the performance of the social protection system: The best policy design and legal framework become meaningless if not backed by sound structures for their financing and implementation. Ensuring a financially sustainable and equitable social protection system remains a challenge especially in developing countries with limited…
Administration and delivery of benefits and services
The efficient governance and administration of social protection schemes is one of the preconditions for the effective realization of human rights. In order to realize their rights, people need to be well informed about the availability of social protection benefits and of qualifying conditions, under which they can access the benefits in case of need.…
Relationship with other human rights
The right to social security implies the relationship to other human rights. This interrelationship has been recognised by the CESCR (General Comment No. 19, para. 28). This is because the right to access and maintain benefits to secure protection from lack of work related income (caused by sickness, disability, maternity, employment injury, unemployment, old age…
Universality of protection and effective access
Social protection programmes must be available to all individuals without discrimination of any kind. Universal social protection systems – those which provide benefits to all residents without conditions – are the best way for States to meet their human rights obligations to ensure that there is no discrimination in the selection of beneficiaries. Further reading:…
Social protection systems
One of the major challenges in social protection is integrating diverse initiatives into genuine systems with the capacity to coordinate programmes with the State institutions responsible for their design, financing, implementation, regulation, monitoring and evaluation, with the aim of raising the population’s living standards. To adequately supply benefits, social protection policies and programmes need to…
Related Principles
Adequacy of Benefits
From a rights-based perspective, the level of benefits provided must be adequate. According to the CESCR’s General Comment 19 (para 22), “Benefits, whether in cash or in kind, must be adequate in amount and duration in order that everyone may realize his or her rights to family protection and assistance, an adequate standard of living…
Standards of Accessibility, Adaptability and Acceptability
The principle of equality and non-discrimination requires States to ensure that social protection programmes meet the standards of accessibility, adaptability, acceptability and adequacy for all rights holders. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) has recommended these standards through several General Comments including 13, 14 and 19. Accessibility means making the social protection…
Adequate legal and institutional framework and long-term social protection strategies
A human rights-based approach to social protection requires grounding social protection systems in a strong legal and institutional framework. This should ensure both programme stability and the recognition of beneficiaries as rights holders. The need to provide for strong legal frameworks that clearly lay out entitlements, rights and obligations is provided for in Recommendation No.…
Comprehensive, Coherent and Coordinated Policies
The interdependence, indivisibility and mutually reinforcing nature of human rights necessitates a holistic approach to social protection. As such, under international human rights law, social protection programmes should be one element within a broader strategy aimed at overcoming poverty and realizing all human rights, including economic, social and cultural rights such as the rights to…
Respect of Privacy
The implementation of social protection schemes requires collecting many types of information including that identifying beneficiaries and their dependants or carers, earnings, employers, contact details, and more. It is essential that the collection of such information is done without breaching the right to privacy. In this regard, personal information should be kept private and free…
Access to Accountability Mechanisms and Effective Remedies
A human rights-based approach to social protection requires that policy makers, programme administrators and others whose actions have an impact on a programme should be held accountable for their actions. To meet this human rights requirement, social protection programmes should have mechanisms to collect and process complaints, in particular to review eligibility for the programme,…
Equality and Non-discrimination
Non-discrimination and equality are core elements of the international human rights normative framework. Article 2 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) states that every human being is entitled to all rights and freedoms “without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin,…
Universality of Protection
States parties to major human rights instruments related to economic, social and cultural rights such as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) have an immediate minimum core obligation to ensure the satisfaction of, at the very least, minimum essential levels of all economic, social and cultural rights such as the right…
Ensure Meaningful and Effective Participation
Meaningful and effective participation of rights holders must be a key component of any social protection system. This is what builds trust and public support behind schemes and ensures that there is a sense of ownership. The participation of right holders is important during the social protection policy making processes but also as regards the…
Ensure Transparency and Access to Information
Element (5) of the Framework for Human Rights-Based Design, Implementation and Evaluation of Social Protection Programmes